Online Terms can be Binding, even if You don’t have to Click!
This past December, a Missouri Court of Appeals held that a user was bound by a website’s terms and conditions, even though she was not obligated to click to signify assent to those terms (Major v. ServiceMagic, Inc.).
The court noted that where a user is obligated to click to signify agreement to terms, such “clickwrap” agreements are routinely enforced. Where clicking is not required, a site’s “browsewrap” agreement usually will be upheld if the user has actual or constructive knowledge of the terms and conditions before using the site.
The court distinguished Specht v. Netscape Communications Corp. In that case, when Netscape allowed users to download certain software, a reference to license terms would have appeared only if the user scrolled further down the page. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit held that the terms would not be enforced because users (a) did not receive reasonable notice of the existence of the terms and (b) did not unambiguously assent to those terms. (Interesting side note: The opinion was written by then Circuit Judge, now Associate Justice of the Supreme Court, Sonia Sotomayor.)
Bottom line: If you want your site’s online terms to be enforced, requiring that the user click to denote acceptance is best, but providing notice of, and a link to, the terms can suffice.
* * *
In Handy v. LogMeIn, Inc. , the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California provided a similar analysis with respect to a different issue. The court granted defendant’s Motion to Dismiss, holding that defendant’s posting on its website a statement that its app may be terminated constituted notice to the plaintiff that such termination was possible.
- Hyperlink in Email Can Create Binding Terms
Dana H. Shultz, Attorney at Law +1 510 547-0545 dana [at] danashultz [dot] com
This blog does not provide legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. If you need legal advice, please contact a lawyer directly.
Contracts, Online Terms
2/9/2011 | 12:00 pm Permalink
This is a very helpful post, thank you for sharing it!
3/7/2011 | 9:17 pm Permalink
normally i don’t post on the blogs i stumble across, but i found this article on quora and it’s been very helpful. thank you!
Trackbacks & Pingbacks
[…] Related post: Online Terms can be Binding, even if You don’t have to Click! […]
How legally binding is a?registration form on a website?…
Are Google’s Terms of Service enforceable?…
I am not as confident as Josh that the correct answer to your question for every user is an unambiguous “Yes.” In “Online Terms can be Binding, even if You don?t have to Click!” (https://danashultz.com/2010/03/01/online-terms-can-be-binding-eve…
How are Terms of Service administered for SMS services?…
I’ve never helped a client with precisely this issue. However, based on what I know about accepting Terms of Service generally, plus a bit of SMS research, I offer the following. The essential issue is to show that the user had actual or constructive …